Shop › 2-Year Cheddar 8oz. Image 1 of 1 2-Year Cheddar 8oz. $9.98 This Cheddar has been aged for 2 years and will have a nice creamy texture with a moderately Sharp flavor. Quantity: Add To Cart Added! This Cheddar has been aged for 2 years and will have a nice creamy texture with a moderately Sharp flavor.